Skip to main content

Rent VS. Sell Calculator

Should I Sell or Rent Out My House?

Compare two paths side by side: sell today and invest the proceeds, or keep the home as a rental and collect rent while it builds equity. Change any number and the results, chart and year-by-year table update to match.

Compare over
Your home today
$
$
Your cost basis, used for the tax on gain.
$
%
yrs
If you rent it out
$
$
%
% of rent collected (typically 8–10%).
%
%
% of home value.
$
Paint, cleaning and repairs before the first tenant.
%
Market & selling
%
%
Commission, title, escrow and concessions.
%
What sale proceeds and rental cash flow earn if invested.
%
Leave at 0 if the primary-residence exclusion covers your gain. See the notes below.
Year by year if you rent it out
YearRent collectedMortgageOther costsNet cash flowHome valueEquityWealth (rent)Wealth (sell now)Difference

personal information

Rent Sell Calculator

property information


property information, continued


personal information


Estimate, not financial advice. Results are based on the numbers you enter and simple assumptions. Talk with your tax, lending and legal advisors before you decide.

Capital gains notes

  • Primary-residence exclusion. If you owned and lived in the home for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale, up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 for most married couples filing jointly) can be tax-free under IRS Section 121. Renting the home for more than about 3 years can mean losing that exclusion, so the tax on a later sale may be higher than the tax if you sell now.
  • Depreciation recapture. Depreciation you take (or could have taken) while the home is a rental is taxed when you sell, even if the exclusion covers the rest of the gain. This calculator does not model it.
  • Tax on gain field. The calculator applies one rate to the gain after selling costs, both today and at the end of the horizon. Leave it at 0% if the exclusion covers you, or ask your tax advisor for your effective rate.
  • Not modeled: income tax on rental profit, a 1031 exchange, and refinancing.

Want a real number for your home?

Get a Free Rental Analysis to see what your home would rent for, or talk with our team about selling.

Or call (480) 916-8900

Terms and Conditions

This Rent Vs. Sell Calculator is provided by Real Estate Brokers of Arizona. By using the Rent Vs. Sell Calculator and clicking the “Calculate” button, you agree that the information and estimates provided are for general information purposes and provided “as-is” without warranties of any kind, expressed or implied, including without limitation the warranties that it is free of defects, errors, viruses, merchantable and that it is fit for a particular purpose. Your usage of the Rent Vs. Sell Calculator is at your own risk. Under no circumstances shall Real Estate Brokers of Arizona be liable for direct, indirect, incidental, special, or consequential damages, resulting from any aspect of your use of the Rent Vs. Sell Calculator including but not limited to damages that arise from your inability to use the Rent Vs. Sell Calculator or the interruption, modification, or termination of the Rent Vs. Sell Calculator or any part thereof.

Scroll to Top